All about the cinema

The Twilight Saga: New Moon film review: only for Twi-hards

newmoon

The phenomenal success of the Twilight and Harry Potter books prove great fortunate can be found in the arena of high school and adolescent coming of age stories, provided tales of classroom dramas, puberty blues and extra curriculum shenanigans can be mingled with more risqué supplements. Harry Potter brought magic, wizards and witches to the play ground; Twilight brings vampires. Other (better) movies have mingled the school setting with concepts like thriller noir (Brick) and politics (Election). Mark my word, it’s just a matter of time until the western genre is revamped with a book/movie series set in cowboy freakin academy, where pubescent six-shooting wannabes go to school to learn the ways of the pistol and, stuffed to the gills with innuendo, the show follows their exploits as they learn how to ride a horse, throw a lasso, refrain from firing their gun too soon…
And, if a hybrid series comes along, how to kill these pesky new age Twilight vampires who play by their own rules and brazenly dishonour long-held traditions of their vampiric predecessors. They are somewhat revisionist blood-suckers – sunlight doesn’t kill them but it does make them sparkle (sigh) and there is nary a mention of garlic or silver – but, if you believe the hype, they are apparently vampires nevertheless.
But Twilight is not a series about vampires or werewolves (though it features both) – it’s a cheesy soap opera about an angsty chick with a crush. Her name Bella (Kristen Stewart) whose blood (correct me if I’m wrong Twi-hards – I know you will anyway) smells particularly potent, or fruity, or something, so naturally her boyfriend is the town’s sexiness vampire Edward (Robert Pattinson) who lusts for her but won’t bite or have sex with her. At least not until instalment #3 or #4. He is 109 years old but has the bod of 19-year-old model.
After a sticky incident at a social gathering Edward decides that being around Bella is bad for her health – no duh – so he moves away and spends most of the movie periodically returning as a half-rendered hologram. In Edward’s absence a new boy muscles in on the scene; his name is Jake (Taylor Lautner) and he’s a werewolf, and werewolves, you see, are perpetually at war with vampires. You might call it a fire and brimstone love triangle but that would imply there was palpable passion or excitement involved. Jake spends much of the story trying to get to first and second base while Bella longs for Edward’s return. Nuf said.
What really surprises about Twilight: New Moon is not that it’s dopey, dumb or low-brow – it’s the startling lack of conviction that lethargically weeps from every inch of the frame, when it can be bothered. The visual structure is bare and vacuous and the special effects are lacklustre. More alarmingly, the actors can’t be assed putting effort into what they’re saying, listlessly enunciating the dialogue like they’re suffering from sleep deprivation or have down a few too many valiums and a spiked drink or two. Makeup on the pasty-faced vampires is so off-putting it makes you wanna walk up to the actors and wipe the white gunk off their faces.
Robert Pattinson appears to have been directed simply to “look cool” on every occasion. Instruction from director Chris Weitz (About a Boy, The Golden Compass) went something like this: “walk across the street…looking cool! Open the door…looking cool! Look at her longingly…looking cool!” But cool this movie is not and neither is he. In fact, if Twlight is your idea of cool, you need some kinda masochistic self-help package: may I suggest inserting a clove of garlic or two where the sun don’t shine, sitting on the pointy end of a silver blade, frying on a banana lounge in the sun and while grapping with your much deserved self-afflicted agony taking a long hard look at yourself.
The profligacy of naked immaculately toned male upper torsos in this movie is staggering; one could be excused for thinking that the town of Forks (where th series is set) enforces some kind of weird arcane rule law that every young man must be buff, polished-teethed Fabio appreciators and must, must, must, be showcasing their flat chests and six packs at all times. This is taken to ridiculously excessive extremes, so much so that Twilight: New Moon deserves to be pegged as soft, soft, soft porn – a pubescent Mills and Boon stomach-turner jazzed up by a half-assed supernatural twist. Lame.

Red lightThe phenomenal success of the Twilight and Harry Potter franchises prove there is great fortune to be found in the arena of high school and adolescent coming of age stories, provided tales of classroom dramas, puberty blues and extra curriculum shenanigans can be mingled with more risqué supplements. Harry Potter brought magic, wizards and witches to the play ground; Twilight brings vampires. Other (better) movies have combined high school settings with concepts like thriller noir (Brick) and politics (Election). Mark my word, it’s just a matter of time until the western genre is revamped with a book/movie series set in cowboy freakin academy, where pubescent six-shooting wannabes go to school to learn the ways of the pistol and, stuffed to the gills with innuendo, the show follows their exploits as they learn how to ride a horse, throw a lasso, refrain from firing their gun too quickly…

And, if a hybrid series comes along, how to kill these pesky new age Twilight-brand vampires who play by their own rules and brazenly dishonour long-held traditions maintained by their vampiric predecessors. They are somewhat revisionist blood-suckers – sunlight doesn’t kill them but it does make them sparkle (sigh) and there is nary a mention of garlic in New Moon – but, if you believe the hype, they are vampires nevertheless.

However, Twilight is not a series about vampires or werewolves (though it features both) – it’s a cheesy soap opera about an angsty chick with a crush. Her name Bella (Kristen Stewart) whose blood (correct me if I’m wrong Twi-hards – I know you will anyway) smells particularly potent, or fruity, or something, so naturally her boyfriend is the town’s sexiest vampire Edward (Robert Pattinson) who lusts for her but won’t bite or have sex with her. At least not until installment #3 or #4. He is 109 years old but has the bod of 19-year-old Kmart model.

After a sticky incident at a social gathering Edward decides that being around Bella is bad for her health – no duh – so he moves away and spends most of the movie periodically returning as a half-rendered hologram. In Edward’s absence a new boy muscles in on the scene; his name is Jake (Taylor Lautner) and he’s a werewolf, and werewolves, you see, are perpetually at war with vampires. You might call it a fire and brimstone love triangle but that would imply there was palpable passion or excitement involved. Jake spends much of the story trying to get to first and second base while Bella longs for Edward’s return. Nuf said.

What really surprises about Twilight: New Moon is not that it’s dopey, dumb or low-brow – it’s the startling lack of conviction that lethargically weeps from every inch of the frame, when it can be bothered. The visual structure is bare and vacuous and the special effects are lacklustre. More alarmingly, the actors can’t be assed putting effort into what they’re saying, listlessly enunciating the dialogue as if they’re suffering from sleep deprivation or have downed a few too many valiums. Makeup on the pasty-faced vampires is so off-putting it makes you wanna walk up to the actors and wipe the white gunk off their faces.

Robert Pattinson appears to have been directed simply to “look cool” on every occasion. Instruction from director Chris Weitz (About a Boy, The Golden Compass) went something like this: “walk across the street…looking cool! Open the door…looking cool! Look at her longingly…looking cool!” But cool this movie is not and neither is he. In fact, if Twlight is your idea of cool, you need some kinda masochistic self-help package: may I suggest inserting a clove of garlic or two where the sun don’t shine, sitting on the pointy end of a silver blade, frying on a banana lounge in the sun and – while grapping with your much deserved self-afflicted agony – taking a long hard look at yourself.

The profligacy of naked, immaculately toned male upper torsos in this movie is staggering; one could be excused for thinking that the town of Forks (where the series is set) enforces some kind of weird arcane rule law stipulating that every young man must be buff, polished-teethed Fabio appreciators and must, must, must, be showcasing their flat chests and six packs at all times. This is taken to ridiculously excessive extremes, so much so that Twilight: New Moon deserves to be pegged as soft, soft, soft porn – a pubescent Mills and Boon stomach-turner jazzed up by a half-assed supernatural twist.

Lame.

The Twilight Saga: New Moon’s Australian theatrical release date: November 19, 2009.

6 Comments

  1. jacoba
    Posted November 21, 2009 at 4:15 pm | Permalink

    wow. it captivated my heart tightly. i love that story. though it is fantasy plot i do not think love which was depicted in movie is a fantasy. it is just feel like tue love. i love that.
    source

  2. Posted November 23, 2009 at 12:42 pm | Permalink

    tue love? too lame.

  3. Gibbot
    Posted November 23, 2009 at 1:31 pm | Permalink

    Mr Onthemoon saved me from having to watch either movie by tweeting this life-saving reader’s digest version. http://tinyurl.com/q4na4w

  4. Posted November 23, 2009 at 3:58 pm | Permalink

    Thanks Gibbot, that’s definitely a much more time economic way of catching the first installment. Reminds me of Mystery Science Theater 3000.

  5. sean
    Posted November 24, 2009 at 1:26 pm | Permalink

    Well, I saw it cos I missed the start of the Coen brother latest – so thats my excuse.

    Yes, it reeks of that self obsessed, vacuous, soap opera psycho pathology that constitutes teen cool. The werewolf vs vampire stuff was pure comedy, as was the slow mo shots of the lead guy – which was the other innovative way of invoking ‘drop dead cool’.

    The girl can not get a shag – or even a kiss – to save her life – which was a tragic element that was left undeveloped. For some reason they chose not to explore the autostimulation that she would unquestionably have been driven to – when she wasnt swooning and pining and seeing holograms of her anemic target model squeeze – which really accounted for 90% of the movie. The six pack shots though (which accounted for the other 10% of the movie) broke new cinematic ground in capturing the essence of pure buffness and were worth the price of a gym admission.

    If you’re prepared to accept that you’re consuming the culinary equivalent of a whippy ice cream at burger king then you’ll be ok…as long as you don’t chuck up afterwards.

  6. fitter
    Posted January 18, 2010 at 2:48 pm | Permalink

    Saw this film, purley to find out what all the hype was about. It was, easliy, the worst, most badly directed, cliched, piece of garbage I have ever sat through. I wish I could get 2 hours of my life back. It was like I was watching a b -grade tele movie. Which makes me question, are there that many stupid teenagers out there? Even as a teenager I would have been embarrassed by this joke of a film. I have not read the books, but, if I were the author, I would be suing the makers of this film for destroying any literary respect she may have once had, as it made the latest installment of star wars look like Citizen Kane…..

5 Trackbacks

  1. ...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Tony Lee, Moonflower Starfire. Moonflower Starfire said: The Twilight Saga: New Moon film review: only for Twi-hards http://bit.ly/4tGPbc [...

  2. ...] role to Kristen Stewart, which is a) an insult to Kristin Scott Thomas and b) further evience that Twilight has irreversibly rottened my mind [thank you Lynden for observing my mental deterioration]) is [...

  3. ...] The Twilight Saga: New Moon Bella and Edward’s second cinematic venture plays like soft, soft, soft porn – a pubescent Mills and Boon stomach-turner jazzed up by a half-assed supernatural twist. Watch the cast sleep walk. [...

  4. ...] Pattison the top gong. I don’t care how well dressed Pattison was – anybody associated with The Twilight Saga: New Moon should be rewarded only via ice and [...

  5. ...] storytelling desperately needed to be rescued from the clutches of Robert Pattinson and associated Twihards comes the second blood-spangled flick from emerging horror writer/directors The Spierig [...

Post a Comment

Register now to join the conversation instantly, or log in to post a comment now.