tip off
8

Cowboys and Aliens movie review: shooting blanks and lost in space

It’s the cross-genre hybrid nobody was waiting for but fanboys who never knew they were fanboys will be giddily anticipating courtesy of the hype synonymous with producers Ron Howard and Steven Spielberg and the manic video game appeal of watching the anachronistic combo articulated in the title: Cowboys and Aliens.

In Eastwood/Leone style, Daniel Craig plays a man with no name; this time ’round because he simply can’t remember it. In New Mexico circa 1875 Craig’s amnesiac character stumbles into ye ol’ desert town of Absolution, the stomping ground of a law enforcing grump, Colonel Dolarhyde (Harrison Ford) and his loose cannon son Percy (Paul Dano).

Human dramas and six-shooter tensions play out before chaos reigns form the sky in the form of extraterrestrial creatures who snatch up helpless victims like corn chips. A posse is formed — Apache Indians included — to, recapturing the words of Will Smith from Independence Day, “whoop ET’s ass.”

Cowboys and Aliens kicks off like a by-the-numbers Hollywood western but the high concept SCI-FI pitch is clear from the start. Other than the title, the extraterrestrial element is embodied by a futuristic looking wristband on Daniel Craig’s arm which flares into life, Buzz Lightyear style, when the fit hits the shan and these darn tooting’ Ameeeericans need a fair dinkum hero.

Harrison Ford spends another running time grumbling like a mad man, attempting to carry the dramatic weight of his performance by the air exhaled through his nostrils.

There is something sad about watching Ford these days, unwilling to let go of his stardom and apparently encountering early senility, with each role exemplifying his status as a has been (ping Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, Morning Glory, Firewall, Hollywood Homicide etcetera).

At this point of his creative nadir Ford would be well advised to take a risk or two, to find an indie director and attach himself to an About Schmidt-esque character piece for well under his salary, to see if he can build some late career cred and reverse his over-the-hill status. It could be another nail in the coffin or it could be a circuit breaker. When you ain’t got much, you ain’t got much to lose.

Sam Rockwell, Daniel Craig and Olivia Wilde — she plays a strange, vacant-eyed character who Knows Things — contribute a trio of lukewarm performances. Their hearts aren’t in it, and you can tell.

A series of ho-hum dramatic encounters leads to an unhinged array of extraneous action scenes full of — you guessed it — cowboys and aliens. Iron Man director Jon Favreau cobbles together some decent moments of throwaway action adventure, but nowhere near enough to fold his disjointed blockbuster-to-be together as a thrilling — or even consistently entertaining — experience. Cowboys and Aliens is cinema as stupid spectacle; the Temple of Dumb.

The lesson reads, in old type carved in the tombstones of at least one dying actor’s career: defeating super-advanced alien creatures is hard enough, but harder still when you have gun toting idiots and Harrison Ford impersonating a shriveled sponge leading the charge.

How depressing that the premise of Cowboys and Aliens relies on connecting two random words. Will this disconcerting process became a habit? Where will it end? Politicians and Dinosaurs? Gladiators and CEOs? Justin Timberlake and the Loch Ness Monster?

Yeah, yeah, alright. Chalk me down for that last one.

Cowboys and Aliens’s Australian theatrical release date: August 18, 2011.

8

Please login below to comment, OR simply register here :



  • 1
    Posted August 16, 2011 at 10:03 am | Permalink

    Thanks for this. I was trying to decide whether to wait for dvd rental or the big screen. Now I know. Wait for Daniel Craig as 007, and watch this when nothing on TV.
    Cheers!

  • 2
    dingbat
    Posted August 16, 2011 at 10:05 am | Permalink

    “Justin Timberlake and the Lock Ness Monster?
    Yeah, yeah, alright. Chalk me down for that last one.”

    *a million scots choke on their McKewan’s Export*
    LOCH Ness monster! Loch!

    But if she’ll eat the Trousersnake, then I’m all for the Lock Ness Monster.

  • 3
    Posted August 16, 2011 at 10:12 am | Permalink

    Good point, typo amended.

    Hopefully it will not be necessary for anybody to eat the Troustersnake…

  • 4
    Posted August 16, 2011 at 12:49 pm | Permalink

    Dang. James Bond + Han Solo/Indiana Jones + Aliens should have been geek heaven, not hell.

    p.s. dingbat – it’s McEwan’s Export not McKewan’s Export (aka McSpewan’s Export).

  • 5
    Siobhan Argent
    Posted August 17, 2011 at 9:21 am | Permalink

    Hi Luke,

    Congratulations on a five-line, comma-free opening sentence that still makes perfect sense. Not many people have that skill! ;-) Shame about the review though. I mean, cowboys and aliens is a bit of a stupid idea, but it did have cred with me because of the casting. Will now think twice about whether it’s worth paying $17 for.

  • 6
    Posted August 19, 2011 at 12:34 pm | Permalink

    I saw this last night and have to say: much better than Wild Wild West.

    I saw Priest a few days earlier, which can also be termed a crossover (dystopia/western/vampires) and that was truly awful.

  • 7
    Paul Bluck
    Posted August 20, 2011 at 1:45 pm | Permalink

    Saw it yesterday, before reading the review. The start of a competently filmed Western destroyed by a silly plot and stupid CGI whizzbangery. A man with no name, no memory and about two facial expressions. Spent some time trying to work out whether Dolarhyde (Harrison Ford’s character) is an anagram for something meaning rubbish – about as close to fun as I got. On the other hand, I have developed an idea for a far better movie with a similar premise …

  • 8
    Posted September 13, 2011 at 2:42 pm | Permalink

    I’m sick of seeing “video game” written as a dismissive term in regards to film by reviewers who haven’t the slightest idea of how far video games have come.

    It’s really quite lazy.

    Can you please be a little more creative in your criticism in future?

Please login below to comment, OR simply register here :



Womens Agenda

loading...

Leading Company

loading...

Smart Company

loading...

StartupSmart

loading...

Property Observer

loading...