tip off
10

The Iron Lady movie review: odious Oscar bait

A glossily shot and dramatically embellished biopic starring an acclaimed actor playing one of the previous century’s most powerful political figures, timed to be released in the thick of awards season scuttlebutt…

This is what industry commentators warily dub “Oscar bait” — productions that appear to be engineered with one fundamental motivation in mind: to collect a trophy case of awards from the film industry’s most coveted annual love-ins.

Appearing in a cameo role in The Extras, Kate Winslet, playing an Oscar-hungry version of herself, explained to Ricky Gervais why she was acting in a film about the Holocaust: “It’s like, how many have there been? We get it. It was grim. Move on. I’m doing it because I’ve noticed that if you do a film about the Holocaust you’re guaranteed an Oscar.”

And if you do a big budget studio film in which you play a legendary politician, you have a great deal more than a fighting chance.

One hopes and assumes the always-reliable Meryl Streep signed onto the role of Margaret Thatcher in The Iron Lady for the right reasons – namely, to provide Britain’s steely-eyed political matriarch the required gravitas. But there is no dulling the question marks that linger like corrosive clouds over director Phyllida Lloyd’s soulless historical re-imagining, cold and homogenized like the yoghurt and milk in its protagonist’s refrigerator.

Lloyd does nothing to convince us her film is after anything less than all-out Oscars glory. The Iron Lady is a Chasers sketch waiting to happen: how to make an Academy Award winning movie 101. Oh wait, they’ve already done it. And their spoof trailer bears some uneasy similarities.

Lloyd spends an inordinate amount of time imagining Thatcher as an old batty lady fending off mental illness and slowly losing her marbles, feeding Streep scene after scene of quivering lips, confused expressions and the required manifestation of stubbornness mixed with repressed fragility. When we meet an over-the-hill 86-year-old Thatcher she tunes out of conversations, forgets names and dates and hallucinates visions of her late husband (played by Jim Broadbent).

The story rewinds to the days before Thatcher came to power and then her time in the UK’s number one job. The film remains, however, more interested in delusional Thatcher than leader Thatcher and barely aspires to shine a light on what was running through her mind when she made difficult decisions, from epic union battles to Britain’s involvement in the Falkands War.

The essence of Thatcher’s character — when she isn’t in repressed fragility mode — boils down to two words emblazoned on proverbial knuckle-busters: tough+love, and the audience are mercilessly bludgeoned across the face with it.

Partisan political wonks beware: viewing The Iron Lady from either a Right or Left perspective will make an unsatisfying experience from both POVs. People on the Left will see a monster dressed up as a warrior of virtue courageously doing what she believes is right, with scenes of protestors picketing and banging against her car half-heartedly thrown in for “balance.” Thatcher fans will see a women who makes brutal decisions that are inadequately explained and a film more interested in showing her frailties than her strengths.

How did Thatcher sway her party to let her lead? How did she convince the population to vote for her? What might she have thought of herself, when her head hit the pillow after a tumultuous day in politics? Did she have regrets? Unfilled ambitions?

The film barely pretends to care. Though its affection for its protagonist is striking, The Iron Lady showcases Thatcher’s most unenviable achievement – going mad – and uses it to colour the ink of her stamp on history. Not in a hard-hitting sense but a “thank gosh, she’s lovely after all.”

It’s hard to tell whether Lloyd is more infatuated with Streep or Thatcher, but ultimately it’s Streep by a powdered nose. The film goes to obscene lengths to remind us this is a Streep fest, from its innumerable makeup-caked close-ups to a laughable technique in which Lloyd plays voice over audio of her star speaking over footage of her mouth not moving. It’s Jackson-esque in its ego-stroking. With help from the editing room, MJ perfected, in songs like Smooth Criminal, the tactic of employing himself as his own back-up singer.

At the end of the film, in case you forgot who you’ve been looking at the whole time, whose tough+love+repressed+fragility face has been leaking with Oscar bait emotion, two words appear at the end of The Iron Lady spelling out — in large elegiac letters — Meryl Streep. They may as well have added “For Your Consideration.”

The Iron Lady’s Australian theatrical release date: December 26, 2011.

7

Please login below to comment, OR simply register here :



  • 1
    paddy
    Posted December 14, 2011 at 5:13 pm | Permalink

    Good to know I don’t have to rush for this one Luke.
    (Just watching the trailer set the B.S. antenna quivering.)
    Such a pity, that with so much budget, cast and studio firepower, they couldn’t come up with a real cracker. :-(

  • 2
    Siobhan Argent
    Posted December 14, 2011 at 9:09 pm | Permalink

    Frost/Nixon showed us tricky Dick at the almost-peak of his power. Focusing on Thatcher’s insane years just makes me think producers can’t make a movie about a politically powerful woman unless she suffers for it.

  • 3
    Posted December 15, 2011 at 8:48 am | Permalink

    I must speak up. I cannot remain silent. I cannot stand by and see good people boycott a good movie.

    Skip it?

    Bah. It’s a flawed script, no question. But at its best, the moments of political drama are thrilling and the personal dramas deeply affecting. The performances are superb; Streep is exceptional.

    It won’t be the greatest film of the year. But it’s pretty bloody good. It’s a green light from me, Margaret. Don’t avoid it.

  • 4
    stan@juc
    Posted December 16, 2011 at 12:57 pm | Permalink

    Thatcher’s potential suffering (if she is now mad, it won’t matter) palls against the suffering this woman inflicted on miners and their families throughout the UK. Thatcher is still revered by the right in the UK and even here, yet her overall ideology and power (shared with Reagan) are now leading to the demise of the capitalist system. It will be interesting to see what is made of her underlying ideology in the film, so I will see it whatever critics say.

  • 5
    John King
    Posted December 18, 2011 at 9:01 pm | Permalink

    Nice to see a thoughtful review of this film as it seems to have disarmed most critics due to its vividly remembered protagonist being intricately realised by Ms Streep & her team. Meryl Streep is an amazing performer, the best in her field?, but Thatcher always seemed to me to be the ultimate ‘ham’. Streep in full flight playing Thatcher in full flight seems to me an over-egged pudding. An interesting question is were any of the English greats asked if they wanted the role … I suspect none of the ‘Dames’ would touch it!

  • 6
    Lawyercat
    Posted January 18, 2012 at 11:15 am | Permalink

    saw it loved it. did not think i would went cos a friend wanted to. gut wrencher.

  • 7
    Rambling Rose
    Posted February 8, 2012 at 10:06 am | Permalink

    How can you label this movie as a “skip it”? Only two comments actually indicated they had seen the movie and recommended it. I saw it and loved it – it’s a 5 star performance from Meryl Streep. Other commentary here is on Thatcher rather than the movie so they don’t count.

3 Trackbacks

  1. ...] lured Oscar voters in the Best Actress category. Academy favourite Meryl Streep got a hat-tip for The Irony Lady and Glenn Close for her bizarre starring role in Albert Nobbs. Rooney Mara’s outstanding  [...

  2. By J Edgar movie review by Luke Buckmaster | Cinetology on January 29, 2012 at 12:47 pm

    ...] as it was wise for Phyllida Lloyd to do the same for Meryl Streep (playing Margaret Thatcher) in Iron Lady (2011). DiCaprio is beautifully made up to remove his perennial boyishness and resemble not just a [...

  3. By Oscars 2012 winners and losers | Cinetology on February 27, 2012 at 6:24 pm

    ...] won her third Oscar (out of a whopping 17 nominations) for her portrayal of Margaret Thatcher in The Iron Lady. Christopher Plummer, 82, became the oldest actor to receive an Oscar (for Beginners). Woody [...

Please login below to comment, OR simply register here :



Womens Agenda

loading...

Leading Company

loading...

Smart Company

loading...

StartupSmart

loading...

Property Observer

loading...