New Monthly editor achieves his majority

I have to say at the off that I have never met Ben Naparstek, 23, new editor of The Monthly. But it is reassuring to see that that Morry Schwartz and Robert Manne have selected someone of better than drinking age. This presumably is to facilitate their regular ‘editorial board’ meetings at Jimmy Watson’s at the Prague end of Carlton’s Lygon St.

A drinker? Maybe. A thinker? Certainly. Of age to take responsibility for, to direct — to edit — a publication that could yet play a significant role in Australia’s life of ideas? Probably not. It’s hard not to see in this appointment the desire of Manne and Schwartz to keep control. To install another ingenue; another cypher for the literary and political ambitions of two mid-life men who apparently lack the chutzpah to do it in their own names. The Monthly, the only magazine of ideas in the world edited by the work experience kid. Maybe they could have made the editorship some sort of tie-in with year 12 english? Or convene it collectively through young Ben’s Facebook page? Or maybe not. We’ll see. Good luck Ben. Take it to them.

5 Comments

  1. Christine Johnson
    Posted May 25, 2009 at 10:23 am | Permalink

    There’s a creepy benevolence to the Manne, Schwartz appointment tinged with swat-back and folly. At this rate Ben’s meteoric rise from playground conkers to literary journalist, broadcaster and Monthly Moshiach should have on the east end of Fleet Street by Hanukkah.

  2. Tom Fairman
    Posted May 25, 2009 at 11:19 am | Permalink

    Holy shitstorm. That’s my age. Christ, way to bring on my quarter life crisis, The Monthly. Now excuse me while I go make my facebook status relevant to the fact…

  3. David Christie
    Posted May 25, 2009 at 3:03 pm | Permalink

    Yeah, well I am over 70 and I don’t think that Mr.Naparstek’s age has the slightest relevance to his editorial ability. I do think that your patronising comments cast a little doubt on your own.

  4. rubbersoul1991
    Posted May 25, 2009 at 10:07 pm | Permalink

    Agree with Mr Christie. Your comments are nothing more than the usual put-down of young people. Maybe he should be clubbing, dropping ees, catching STD’s and maybe stealing cars. Then he might conform to your stereotype of young people. I would have expected better from Crikey. And I am aged 45 thank you.

  5. deccles
    Posted May 26, 2009 at 2:56 pm | Permalink

    I certainly wont be renewing my subscription to ‘The Monthly’. Losing Gideon Haigh is bad enough but the new editor needed to be someone who could edit Manne. Talent to write does not guarantee that you have the talent to edit.

    The age of the new editor will only become relevant if the quality of ‘The Monthly’ declines even further.

    *insert cliche about eating puddings here*

2 Trackbacks

  1. By The Monthly maelstrom « a lack of alignment on May 28, 2009 at 12:00 am

    ...] commentators who simply couldn’t hide their amusement. Crikey’s Jonathan Green had a chortle about it. While I respect Green’s point that—given the reported stoush between Warhaft and [...

  2. By I could have cats » The Monthly maelstrom on August 17, 2009 at 3:06 pm

    ...] and some commentators simply couldn’t contain their amusement. Crikey’s Jonathan Green chortled. While I respect Green’s point that—given the reported stoush between Warhaft and chairman [...

Post a Comment

Register now to join the conversation instantly, or log in to post a comment now.