tip off
7

MH370: Media plunges into disaster porn and RSR*

The news vacuum in the wake of the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 is starting to suck in the daft and desperate when it comes to media coverage

More really stupid reporting or RSR, courtesy CNN

Although a sudden breakthrough in the search zone could happen at any minute, it may never happen, and the news vacuum in the wake of the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 is starting to suck in the daft and desperate when it comes to media  coverage.

The CNN screen grab above may seem funny, unless you work in the media, or have lost a loved one on the flight. It’s just another all too common example of RSR or really stupid reporting.

But some of the reporting is also deeply offensive. When a non-flying reporter, and most reporters couldn’t even fly a small light aircraft, hops in a 777 simulator and breathlessly re-enacts the death dive scenarios for an airliner that runs out of fuel at altitude, this is nothing less than an embarrassment.

Getting a 777 check captain to actually take the viewers through the various things that would then happen may have a justification.  But there wouldn’t be all that many such qualified pilots that would be comfortable doing that, or willing to participate in satisfying the popular media taste for disaster porn.

Reporters flicking console switches in a 777 cockpit and saying “look how easy it is to disable the transponder, or ACARS” in a disapproving mock moralistic tone, as if to say, look how derelict the designers were, is ridiculous.

If such devices couldn’t be turned off when aircraft are on the ground, they couldn’t be serviced, or reset, and the massive amounts of useless data generated would prevent modern air transport working at all. It is the witlessness of this reporting into a vacuum when there is no MH370 progress to report that helps what is left of the professional media to marginalise its own value.

It is more than reasonable at this stage to fear that an act of evil, motivated by unknown purposes or perhaps facilitated by mental illness, happened on board MH370, and took the lives of all 239 people on board.

But that isn’t a certainty either. Nothing is certain at this stage other than the fact that the airliner has crashed somewhere, and there is a very, very high probability it crashed in the southern Indian Ocean, some considerable distance to the west or south-west of Perth, on the morning of 8 March.

What is a legitimate MH370 story? The attempts at message management, or if we wish, dubious standards of disclosure at the highest levels of authority, are arguably very important.  Covering the integrity of messaging in politics, public administration, consumer affairs, and, way down the list, aviation, is something that serious media seeks to address.

When Prime Ministers and senior Ministers hold a media briefing, those too are legitimate stories, even if the news, so far, has been terrible.  There are good stories to be found in the actual search operations, since such capabilities and processes have an importance that always transcends and outlasts the tragedy that is MH370.

But in the meantime, and perhaps for a long time, the tendency of some media to salivate or engage in mock hand wringing over MH370 and the misery of its living victims ought to be resisted, if not despised.

7

Please login below to comment, OR simply register here :



  • 1
    paddy
    Posted April 2, 2014 at 10:17 am | Permalink

    Yet again, the voice of sanity at Plane Talking.
    Thanks Ben.

  • 2
    Geoff
    Posted April 2, 2014 at 12:21 pm | Permalink

    Ben – I am still waiting expectantly for the eye witness reports of “MH370 snatched in mid-air by flying saucer” to appear!

  • 3
    Nev from MCY
    Posted April 2, 2014 at 1:13 pm | Permalink

    Well said Ben! Some of the theories floating around would make a pretty good base for a Tom Clancy novel.

  • 4
    Tango
    Posted April 2, 2014 at 1:43 pm | Permalink

    When unreal TV can be labeled “Reality Show” and they don’t get laughed off the planet you know we are doomed.

    I felt there was a legitimate purpose served when I postulated it was human caused as the search was going on in the wrong location and then continued so for far too long

    Now its become grist for the un-reality mill and we will get the worst.

    There were some early well done pieces considering how short a time they were given.

    Sadly, maybe the best we can hope for is nothing, it fades and the people who really care about the industry can quietly go on with their work and see if it can be found. I don’t hold out any hope at this point unless we get really lucky and the RN Nuke boat picks up the pinger.

    I never did hear why the AF447 pinger did not work though.

  • 5
    erikhb
    Posted April 2, 2014 at 3:03 pm | Permalink

    When I grew up, there were only two reality shows on the TV, and they ran once a day, except Sundays:
    News, and Sport.

    It is sad to see the proliferation of poor quality reporting these days. Good to have this blog as a high quality source of aviation-related news, at least. Keep it going, it is highly appreciated.

  • 6
    aking
    Posted April 2, 2014 at 4:48 pm | Permalink

    Ben:Did you notice that on ABC-TV news reports last night, they were quoting the last words on the transcript as “Good night MALAYSIA three seven zero”?
    Rather than the proper call sign Malaysian

    I suspect if the word Malaysia had in fact been used, that would have been cause for concern;

    Sloppy ABC reporting !

  • 7
    R. Ockape
    Posted April 2, 2014 at 8:15 pm | Permalink

    A really valuable article Ben which should be mandatory reading for every reporter who goes near an aircraft related story. Every time I read an article penned by a journo who clearly doesn’t have the first idea about aircraft operations, I shake my head at the repeated inaccuracies. I suddenly realised that if I felt that way about the articles about which I knew something, then it was a pretty fair bet that most of the rest of the rag was only fit for fish and chip wrappings too.

Please login below to comment, OR simply register here :



Womens Agenda

loading...

Smart Company

loading...

StartupSmart

loading...

Property Observer

loading...