Reflections on the Miracle of Democracy at Work in the Greatest Nation on Earth

Nielsen: 53-47

   

The latest monthly Nielsen survey, published in the Fairfax broadsheets, has Labor’s two-party lead at 53-47, down from 54-46 last time. Labor and the Coalition are equal on 42 per cent of the primary vote, with Labor steady and the Coalition up a point. The Prime Minister’s approval rating is down three points on a month ago, and nine points on two months ago, to 57 per cent; his disapproval rating is 37 per cent, compared with 33 per cent last time and 29 per cent the time before. Tony Abbott’s approval rating has bounced six points to 50 per cent, while his disapproval is steady on 41 per cent. Over the past three surveys, Kevin Rudd’s lead as preferred prime minister has gone from 67-21 to 58-31 to 57-35. Following last week’s health reform announcement, 79 per cent of respondents supported a greater funding role for the federal government. The poll was conducted from Thursday to Saturday from a sample of 1400.

A fair bit of legislative action to report:

• Federal parliament is currently considering a piece of legislation called the Electoral and Referendum Amendment (Close of Rolls and Other Measures) Bill, which looks likely to give effect to a number of changes in time for the federal election. Three measures in particular have the support of the Coalition: treating pre-poll votes cast within the electorate as normal rather than declaration votes, so they can be counted on election nights; allowing enrolment to be updated online; and preventing parties’ registered officers from nominating multiple candidates in a single electoral division. The latter measure will prevent a repeat of the Bradfield by-election, at which the Christian Democratic Party was effortlessly able to complicate the process by indulgently nominating nine candidates. The party would now be required to find 50 nominators for each candidate after the first, as is required of independents. Two further measures are opposed by the Coalition, both of which seek to reverse unconscionable amendments made by the Howard government in 2005. One is a return to the seven-day period after the issue of writs allowing new voters to enrol or existing voters to amend their enrolment, against which no reasonable argument can be raised. The other seeks to repeal the requirement that those casting provisional voters provide identification to the AEC after polling day, which many neglected to do after the 2007 election. Antony Green reviews the closure of rules issue specifically here, and the legislation in general here.

• The Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters has completed its inquiry into the New South Wales parliament’s automatic enrolment legislation. The government shares the bipartisan enthusiasm for the concept in New South Wales, but a dissenting report has signalled that any similar move at federal level will be opposed by the Coalition in the Senate. This has not impressed University of Queensland electoral law boffin Graeme Orr, who runs through his concerns with the Coalition’s position in Crikey.

• Legislation abolishing tax deductibility of donations to parties, members and candidates, and limiting deductions for gifts and contributions by businesses, completed its passage through parliament on February 25.

And as always, a whole lot happening on the preselection front:

• Saturday’s much-publicised Labor preselection ballot for Robertson saw the defeat of incumbent Belinda Neal at the hands of university lecturer Deborah O’Neill, by a margin of 98 to 67. A prescient article on Thursday by Andrew Crook of Crikey indicated Neal could rely on only 66 votes from the three branches she controlled – Woy Woy, Kariong and Mangrove Mountain – whereas Deborah O’Neill had the support of “at least 100” preselectors UPDATE: This is disputed by a commenter who says the Kariong branch voted unanimously for O’Neill.

• New South Wales Labor Senator Michael Forshaw has made life easier for his party by announcing he will not contest the next election. This leaves a vacancy for outgoing state party secretary Matt Thistlethwaite, who needed to be accommodated after he agreed to go quietly from his current position on the condition a Senate seat would be available to him. Both Thistlethwaite and Forshaw are members of the Right. A report by Imre Salusinszky of The Australian suggests he was pushed as much as jumped, saying the result was determined by “a meeting of right-wing unions and party officials”. The sequence of candidates will be John Faulkner, Matt Thistlethwaite and Steve Hutchins, the latter managing to cling on to a winnable-yet-loseable position because of “strong support from the powerful Shop Distributive and Allied Employees Association”.

• South Australian Liberal Senator Alan Ferguson has announced he will not contest the next election, and will retire when his term expires in the middle of next year. This was foreshadowed in reports last year which suggested the vacancy was likely to be contested between former Wakefield MP David Fawcett, who like Ferguson is associated with the Right, and state party president Sean Edwards, a moderate.

• I learned from Joe Hockey on Insiders yesterday morning that Office of Aboriginal Health director Ken Wyatt has won Liberal preselection for the marginal Labor seat of Hasluck in eastern Perth. Hockey pointed out that if elected, Wyatt will become “the first Indigenous Australian to sit in the House of Representatives”. I’m wondering if he might be any relation to state Labor rising star Ben Wyatt (Shadow Treasurer and member for Victoria Park), who is part Aboriginal and the son of the Liberal candidate for Kalgoorlie at the 1996 federal election.

• The New South Wales Liberals have finalised preselections for those state upper house candidates who are chosen centrally rather than regionally (David Clarke being an example of the latter). The three winnable positions have gone to incumbent Catherine Cusack; Natasha Maclaren-Jones, state party vice-president and adviser to Senator Helen Coonan; and Peter Phelps, an adviser to Senator Michael Ronaldson and formerly to defeated Eden-Monaro MP Gary Nairn. Out in the cold was Dai Le, an ABC documentary producer who will have to content herself with a second tilt at unwinnable Cabramatta. Phelps has his admirers (“a very smart chap”, reckons politically moderate former party identity Irfan Yusuf), but they don’t include many who place a premium on standards of decency in public life. Highlights of a dangerous life include an appearance at a public forum at which he heckled Mike Kelly, soon-to-be Labor member for Eden-Monaro, comparing him to a Nazi concentration camp guard on the basis of his distinguished service in Iraq. In October, an email he wrote on media strategy with the candid subject heading “digging dirt” was released to the media: it recommended MPs pursue stories about “fat cat public servants not caring about taxpayers, pollies with snouts in the trough, special interest groups getting undeserved handouts from tax taken from hard-working Aussies, a favoured pro-Labor contractor who seems to be getting all the work for a particular job etc”.

• Margot Saville of Crikey writes that Leichhardt mayor Jamie Parker is expected to win Greens endorsement in the state seat of Balmain, where the party appears a better-than-even chance of toppling Labor incumbent Verity Firth.

Plus some other stuff:

• The process for a redistribution of Victorian federal electorates has begun, but with an expected date of completion of December 17, it is very unlikely to take effect before this year’s election.

• Simon Benson of The Daily Telegraph reported on Wednesday that “the chance of Australia going to an early election has lessened with internal Labor research exposing a negative shift in mood towards Prime Minister Kevin Rudd in key marginal seats in Sydney’s west” – namely Lindsay, Macquarie, Greenway and Macarthur. In particular, we were told that “women had begun to sour on Mr Rudd and that mixed messages were now starting to show up on the Government’s climate change policy”. Labor national secretary Karl Bitar wrote on Twitter shortly afterward that the story was “not true”.

Peter Brent at Mumble urges the government to caution over the question of holding a referendum concurrent with the next election: firstly because history suggests referendum results bear little relationship to the question being posed, and secondly because there is reason to believe referendums on election day drag down support for the government.

• Gareth Griffith of the New South Wales Parliamentary Library has published two very interesting papers on the the record of minority government in Australia and the prospect of recall elections in New South Wales (the latter with Lenny Roth). The former covers similar territory to a paper I presented on minority government and the Greens at the Australian Study of Parliament Group conference in September, which will be published in the next edition of the Australasian Parliamentary Review.

• Owing to a public holiday in Victoria, Essential Research will publish its weekly survey on Tuesday, and not today as it normally does.

3,631 Comments

Pages: « 169 70 71 72 [73] Show All

  1. 3601
    Hamish Coffee
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:08 pm | Permalink

    Vote 1 Barry O”Farrell as soon as possible!

    Ah, no.

  2. 3602
    Cuppa
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:08 pm | Permalink

    Vp

    I’m with whoever it was – Nietzsche? – that said if god didn’t exist man would have to invent him… But that’s all I’m saying on this; I can see William’s hand coming down from above to spank us for going seriously OT. ;)

  3. 3603
    Gary Bruce
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:08 pm | Permalink

    NSW Planning Minister Tony Kelly told Fairfax Radio that compensation for compulsory land purchases would probably be based on a British model that the former owners a share in any increase in the value resulting from rezoning for development.

    http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/keneally-slams-scaremongering-as-she-refuses-to-rule-out-compulsory-purchase-of-private-land-20100312-q2wz.html

  4. 3604
    Laocoon
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:08 pm | Permalink

    On the 2nd April 2009 five judges of the High Court unanimously agreed that it was illegal for local government to use its powers of compulsory acquisition in this way. So, in a defiant snub to the High Court, Parramatta Council announced it would ask the New South Wales Government to introduce new legislation to overturn the decision.

    Then, on 14th May 2009 an amendment to the Land Acquisitions Act was introduced and passed which allows local councils in New South Wales to compulsorily acquire roads, and then compulsorily acquire any adjacent property or any property in the vicinity of that road.

    http://www.savepropertyrights.com.au/index.php

  5. 3605
    Listy
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:10 pm | Permalink

    Just for fun, I just went through the entire list of contributors to the ABC Unleashed blog and tallied up all the contributions by current (or ex) politicians. (It may not be 100% accurate, as it was a somewhat tedious exercise!)
    Since the site started up in 2007, there have been:

    Liberals – 14 authors for a total of 20 stories
    Nationals – 1 author, 2 stories
    Labor – 5 authors and 5 stories
    Greens – 5 authors and 5 stories
    Democrats – 1 author / 1 story

    Make of that what you will …

  6. 3606
    Bushfire Bill
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:10 pm | Permalink

    Kindly justify this position.

    But they are fools Psephos. They should be told that.

    The only differnece between telling fools that deny Climate Change that they are, in fact, fools and telling believers in God the same thing seems to be the size of the collective delusion.

    What you’re basically saying is that if the Climate Change Deniers should ever get a decent poll ratio for their theory (I doubt whether it’d have to be even much mopre than 30%) then this trumps all the science to the contrary. You’re saying that because people believe something then it’s immaterial whether it’s actually true or not.

    Therefore why not give anti-Climate Change activists a decent chance to present their case, in any way they see fit. In other words, show me where Maurice Newman was out of line suggesting that something which is accepted by 16% of the population – that there is no anthropogenic Climate Change – shouldn’t get a decent covrage, much more than it gets now?

  7. 3607
    rossco
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:10 pm | Permalink

    Morgan poll just out

  8. 3608
    rossco
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:11 pm | Permalink

    In early March support for the ALP is 55.5% (down 1%) maintaining a strong two-party preferred lead over the L-NP (44.5%, up 1%) according to the latest Face-to-Face Morgan Poll conducted over the last two weekends (February 27/28 & March 6/7, 2010).

    If a Federal Election were held today the ALP would still win easily, according to the Morgan Poll.

    The ALP primary vote is 45% (unchanged), ahead of the L-NP (38.5%, up 1%), while looking at the minor parties shows support for the Greens (8.5%, down 0.5%), Family First (2%, down 0.5%) and Independents/ Others (6%, unchanged).

  9. 3609
    don
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:13 pm | Permalink

    Ron@3550:

    Do youse anti religon people know people in th Gay activist forum or th pedefile protection forum

    Ron, that was uncalled for.

  10. 3610
    Ron
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:13 pm | Permalink

    th idiotic zeel of particular anti religious Athiest here is sewer level , even for a General Net Site

    To go out of your way you anti religious gutter snipes to infect a POLITCAL Site with you iner biased hatreds , shows you do NOT even respect your fellow (quiet) Athiests here who simple want to blog only politcs

    and these moronic obsessed anti religious posters ideas ar PY , j/v , Bushfire bill, Diogenes , Show Off , and on th sly BK , and am happy to add to list

    And Adam a sanctimonous smug , you happy to sit quiet hypocrit with bile anti religious posts , well it goes both ways from now to th specific sleeze Athiiest here

  11. 3611
    Gary Bruce
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:14 pm | Permalink

    3607 – and according to Morgan himself Tone is really going places. LOL.

  12. 3612
    Bushfire Bill
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:15 pm | Permalink

    Anyway, enough arguing over God and the ABC. I’m off for a few hours. If I don’t reply to anyone’s posts calling me a weasel or an anti-religious zealot, or trying to prove God exists, or doesn’t exist, don’t take a lack of reply from me as a sign I’ve been flummoxed or left floundering in the wake of your superior arguments etc. etc.

    I’m just going off to walk my dogs, have dinner, watch a movie and forget about politics for a while.

  13. 3613
    Cuppa
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:15 pm | Permalink

    Morgan reports:

    ...Family First (2%, down 0.5%)

    Galling that the vote of the unrepresentative tool Fielding gets to help torpedo important legislation that he probably doesn’t even personally grasp or understand. I hope the Victorians make HIM a one-termer.

  14. 3614
    Laocoon
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:15 pm | Permalink

    GB – 3603

    NSW Planning Minister Tony Kelly told Fairfax Radio that compensation for compulsory land purchases would probably be based on a British model that the former owners a share in any increase in the value resulting from rezoning for development.

    BTW, I dont have any particular stats to evidence this, but my sense is that UK CPOs (Compulsory Purchase Orders) are considerably more common than Australian land resumptions for private developments

  15. 3615
    vera
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:15 pm | Permalink

    The good thing about Morgan is that Labor’s primary is staying put at 45% (not dropping)
    Greens down Libs up….. could it be some Greens figure they may as well vote for the organ grinder instead of monkey? :evil:

  16. 3616
    Scarpat
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:15 pm | Permalink

    Geez centre, you are sounding like the Daily Terror!

    Vera, more like the SMH.

  17. 3617
    jaundiced view
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:16 pm | Permalink

    jv, I am so enraged with the policy that I would truly vote for Costello (if he was leader) federally because of it.

    Yes, maintain the rage Centre, but maybe at a slightly lower level from here on, seeing you are talking about voting for Costello. :lol:

    But I don’t see it a communism – the proles won’t get the benefit. As Bushfire Bill suggested they will sell it off cheaply to their mates to whom they owe favours.

    This is what has happened before in a more secretive way. The minister lets a developer donor mate know on the quiet of a state zoning plan in western Sydney a year or two in advance, the mate quietly buys tracts of land at rural prices (a segment on the secret behalf of government figures). Then bingo – what luck – the government rezones the land as residential. Everyone wins … well the developer mate and the party power brokers’ families do anyway.

    Why the government thinks making this rort ‘official’ will be acceptable to the people is beyond me.

  18. 3618
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:17 pm | Permalink

    But they are fools Psephos. They should be told that.

    Sorry BB, but I live in the real world, not the fantasy planet you seem to inhabit. You refuse to engage with the fact that the Australian people own and pay for the ABC, and that it has a duty to reflect the interests and values of Australian society, including the fact that 70-80% of Australians hold religious beliefs. The analogy with climate science is false. The reality of climate change is a scientific fact and should be stated as such. The truth or falsity of metaphysical beliefs cannot be proved (that’s why they’re metaphysical), and can only be a matter of faith or lack thereof.

  19. 3619
    don
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:18 pm | Permalink

    Vera@3589:

    Next thing they’ll be telling us that the jails are full of Christians :P

    So far as I remember, that is a true statement, the jails are full of christians. Were you being ironic?

  20. 3620
    jaundiced view
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:20 pm | Permalink

    *back later with the definitive wisdom on all the above from the local RSL*

  21. 3621
    Gary Bruce
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:20 pm | Permalink

    It seems the scaremongering in NSW is working a treat.

  22. 3622
    vera
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:20 pm | Permalink

    Don
    No athiests in jail then?

  23. 3623
    Scarpat
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:21 pm | Permalink

    No athiests in jail then?

    Nope. All been crucified.

  24. 3624
    vera
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:21 pm | Permalink

    gary
    the scaremongering is only working on those who hate NSW labor and wouldn’t ever have voted for them anyway.

  25. 3625
    Ron
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:22 pm | Permalink

    Bushfire Bill
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 4:53 pm | Permalink

    “The amusing thing is that I’m not Ron’s enemy. I just disagree with him, and I have science on my side.”

    why do you not take a copy of your vile posts to Kevin Rudd or a Paul Keating of beliefs in ferrys , you will not hav th courage

    what i said is you can hav any damn opinion you like , but if its religon go to a relgous Site This is a POLITCAL site

    but you PY , j/v , Diogenes , Show Off , and on th sly BK hav decided to infect this site with your bile anti religous views Youse were asked over a number of daysto go to a Religous site with your anti religous ideas

    Youse refuse to do so , so now there will be 2 way fire

  26. 3626
    ruawake
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:23 pm | Permalink

    jv

    Ever heard of “land banking”? This is a speculative property investment – hoping that the land gets re-zoned. It has happened for yonks.

    Your insinuation of corruption is bollocks. Oh those poor rural landholders were forced to sell?

  27. 3627
    don
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:23 pm | Permalink

    Vera@3622:

    No athiests in jail then?

    LOL! There may be a few!

    But I seem to remember there is a higher proportion of christians in jail than outside, though that stat may only be true for the US. I don’t know if the stats have been done for Oz.

  28. 3628
    Centre
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:23 pm | Permalink

    Hell jv @ 3617, I might even switch to Abbott.

  29. 3629
    vera
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:23 pm | Permalink

    gary, espescially the greens who think they are going to win more seats than Labor at the next elextion ;)

  30. 3630
    ltep
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:25 pm | Permalink

    The truth or falsity of metaphysical beliefs cannot be proved (that’s why they’re metaphysical), and can only be a matter of faith or lack thereof.

    exactly. This reminds me o the time soneone was arguing over the existance of the soul.

  31. 3631
    Posted Friday, March 12, 2010 at 5:26 pm | Permalink

    New thread.

Pages: « 169 70 71 72 [73] Show All