Film reviews

Oct 16, 2012

Lawless movie review: ground-rattling acting in prohibition era thriller

Director John Hillcoat's terrifically acted prohibition era thriller, inspired by the real-life story of the Bondurant brothers, shows how the American dream starting to go wrong -- before it even existed.

Luke Buckmaster — Writer, Critic and The Daily Review Journalist

Luke Buckmaster

Writer, Critic and The Daily Review Journalist

If you go to the cinema to watch prohibition era thriller Lawless, Australian-born director John Hillcoat’s second adaptation of a screenplay penned by Nick Cave, best to ensure the building’s foundations are sound, the load bearing walls secure, the emergency exits accessible…

Screens are only able to take so much, stay vertical for so long, keep attached to the wall. When the heft of Lawless’ ground-rattling performances — a dream of testosterone-infused ensemble casting — kicks in, you wouldn’t want to be standing directly under it.

Tom Hardy is again the man’s-man-man’s-man. He plays moonshine makin’ hard guy Forrest Bondurant, the kind of fella who lectures you about manners after smashing a bottle of whiskey on your head. Again, even in this post-Bane society, even in this pre-Bane picture, Hardy has some seriously gnarly issues with his voice box.

Shia LaBeouf gives his most nuanced performance yet as Hardy’s younger and naiver bro Jack. Noah Taylor looks wan and food-deprived as one of the henchmen of Gary Oldman, who pops up in a high-impact bit part as one of the film’s many bootleg al-cee-hol buying law-breakers.

But it’s a ghostly pale-skinned Guy Pearce as Charlie Rakes who steals the show, almost single handedly shifting the film from a gritty drama to a rustic thriller. Rakes is an oil-slick hard-hitting city cop sent to the sticks to break up the illegal syndicate of the Bondurant Brothers, whose real-life story inspired the film.

Pearce’s performance is deeper than his character, who eventually crumbles into the realms of caricature, if only a little, and in the film’s final, deep, confrontational breaths. But it’s worth it.

Lawless gathers focus as it steams along, Cave’s screenplay erring towards LaBeouf as the protagonist as it maintains a drafty sense of realism. You never know when characters will appear or disappear for sizable chunks of running time, which helps make the interpersonal relationships feel broad but close, loose but unsettling. It also gives the story a wandering unpredictability, a sense of entangled lives and moments that pass us by….

You’d call them vignettes if Hillcoat took the easier route, emphasised them as self-contained pockets of tension. Instead they exist as a kind of tumbling ball of uneasiness underscored by a simmering sense of dread, of danger closing in, and the Australian-born director brings all this together with a fluid sense of mystique.

The film is shot and edited beautifully, Benoît Delhomme’s cinematography capturing rustic Americana with a luscious and loving lens, soaking up the wood and greenery and shacks and guns like a sponge.

Lawless captures a time when formal notions of the American Dream were a while away, past some distant academic horizon, but you can see almost see it actualising, growing through the grass and rustling in the leaves. The dream of success, of owning land and protecting your interests, of personal enterprise, getting a family, making a stake in a man’s world, keeping a gun close by.

We can see how it started to go wrong before it really existed: a sweltering disdain for authorities, the danger of franchised black markets, the rise of criminals linked more to underworld commerce than moral wrongdoing, the delusion of a collective conscience in a world of gang wars and bit parts and irreconcilable ideologies, the fear and blood that marks it.

“You even believe your own legend,” Tom Hardy’s wifey-wife character, played by Jessica Chastain, tells the supposedly immortal boulder-of-a-man. She might as well be addressing the country as a whole, daring it to come to terms with its own foibles, challenging perceptions of a limitless shelf life.

Lawless’ Australian theatrical release date: October 11, 2012. 


Leave a comment

3 thoughts on “Lawless movie review: ground-rattling acting in prohibition era thriller

  1. joanjett

    I’m reading the review of Killing Them Softly too and it struck me that Ben Mendelsohn and Noah Taylor are looking more and more similiar as their faces crumple into character actor mode. Interesting that they had their debut in the same film!

  2. joanjett

    I like the proposition very much but this plot kind of sounds like the Untouchables (and the stills also look like it too).
    Having said that I’m a huge Nick Cave fan so I’ll definitely go and see it(even though sometimes it appears he too believes his own hyperbole!)

  3. Stephen

    For me, Pearce derailed the show, rather than stealing it. Too close to Priscilla of the Desert for my liking.

    I agree, this is a terrific-looking sheen of a movie, but the script and plotting could have been more subtle.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details