The Fall of Rome: ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s Lecture

ABC Managing Director Mark Scott is, at this very moment, getting to his feet to give the AN Smith Lecture in Journalism at the University of Melbourne. Titled The Fall of Rome: Med

Margaret Simons

Journalist, author and director of the Centre for Advanced Journalism

ABC Managing Director Mark Scott is, at this very moment, getting to his feet to give the AN Smith Lecture in Journalism at the University of Melbourne. Titled The Fall of Rome: Media After Empire, it has been billed as a landmark statement. It fulfills that promise, while not containing any earth shattering revelations or instant solutions to the problems facing media.

You can read the lecture here.

Mark Scott gives a good speech – well written and for the most part, well judged.  It will be interesting to see what the mainstream media make of it, if anything, because despite its undoubted significance there is no easy news point or grab. The obvious route would be to pick up on his criticism of Rupert Murdoch’s plans to make people pay for content. Scott depicts this as the last frantic efforts of a media emperor to:

deny a revolution that’s already taken place by attempting to use a power that no longer exists, by trying to impose on the world a law that is impossible to enforce.

No media company has solutions to the collapse of business models and the new threats, says Scott.

For newspapers, the last great hope now seems to be something called Waiting for Rupert, the man who just four years ago said he wanted to “make the necessary cultural changes to meet the new demands of the digital native” says he’s not going to respond to the demands of these digital natives.  Instead, they – who have never in their lives paid for news online – will be asked to respond instead to his demands and start paying..

The mission to make people pay for content will not work and cannot work, except for a few highly specialised high quality brands, says Scott. I think this is one area of the speech where Scott’s bark is bigger than his bite. Read carefully, and he says a pay model will work for some things. Yet his language is more condemnatory than that message would suggest.

The reason for this slight slippage in rhetoric is in the speech itself. Scott knows that the commercial media organisations are “after” public broadcasters, attacking their right to exist in the new world of media plenty. He is joining the battle.

But more significant  is Scott’s central message that power has shifted to the audiences, and that this cannot be resisted, but must be embraced.

News gatherers cannot compete with the audience, who are everywhere and now able to publish to the world with elan and efficiency. We no longer live in a world in which ownership of a printing press or a broadcasting licence brings unique  power. They very strategies and thinking that built the media empires may now be the things that bring them undone.

Scott depicts the ABC as living in a constant state of fear that it is not moving “fast enough or bold enough to meet the challenge of the times”. Personally, I think that’s a healthy kind of fear. I’d rather be frightened of not changing than frightened of change.

Scott  is thinking in terms of “ten thousand channels, not five delivered to your living room”  and constant reinvention.The ABC is asking:

What is television? What is radio? In doing so, we are questioning nothing less than the very foundations upon which the ABC has been built over the course of 77 years.  You have to be ready to be truly bold.

He reprises the idea of a public “broadcasters” role as being a town square in which citizens can meet and discuss their affairs.

Scott’ speech begins with the feel of an elegy. He quotes an Auden poem on the fall of the Roman Empire, and continues with better turns of phrase than those who used to sub his copy on the Sydney Morning Herald would have expected to find.

He continues through a nice framing of the challenges and the struggles of the declining empires, and ends with some “hestitant suggestions” about the way forward. He says that the only media organisations that will survive are those that accept that all the rules have changed.

The future lies, not in owning everything but in being part of something. This means that the audience “long treated with an oligipolist’s disdain” must be treated with real respect and their contribution valued.

Scott’s central message is about a shift in power relationships from owners to audiences and participants. This is a hard message for any commercial media company to swallow.

It is no accident, of course, that the public broadcaster takes the debate forward. Only public broadcasters can embrace audience fragmentation and is unphased by collapsing business models.  And there is a natural fit between content makers already directly in the pay of the public and the new imperative to embrace audience power.

It is hard, if not impossible, for a stock market owned media company focussed on quarterly results to innovate and experiment with the depth and speed that is necessary to even hope to keep up.

That is why the ABC is more important now than since its creation. Its new justification for existance includes innovation and experimentation at a time of collapsing business models and paradigm change in media. And that is why we can expect it to come under increasingly fierce attack from all of those who want to make audiences pay for content.

I think the battle between public broadcasters on the one hand, and those who want to make us pay for content will be the key media fight in the early part of this century.  It will be of more lasting importance than the ructions in the Fairfax Board, to name just one set of agonies.

It might be described as the battle between “control” media and “participatory” media. (Thanks to Bronwen Clune for those terms).

Scott’s speech should be seen in that context.

(Visited 208 times, 1 visits today)


Leave a comment

19 thoughts on “The Fall of Rome: ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s Lecture

  1. wildgoose

    I’ve read and enjoyed all the brahoo over this topic and I constantly get drawn back to the old story about buggywhip salesmen. Goodbye Rupert, goodbye mogul media empires, you sanctimonious old bastards are going, going, gone……..

  2. Foxtel’s Kim Williams Takes the Fight Up to “Old Television”, Government and the ABC – The Content Makers

    […] speech is another blow in what I have previously described as one of the most important battles of the new media century –  between those who want to […]

  3. Weekly links (weekly) | Frontiering Talk

    […] The Fall of Rome: ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s Lecture – The Content Makers […]

  4. The ABC and Ozco: Cultural change and how (not) to adapt to it

    […] chief Mark Scott is speaking to the forum tonight. Last week he gave the AN Smith Memorial Lecture in Journalism at Melbourne University. Speaking of the media landscape, he chided the growling demands of old […]

  5. De media en het Romeinse rijk: 5 ‘hesitant suggestions’ om de ondergang af te wenden | Publishr

    […] Een recente lezing van Mark Scott, chef van de Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) houdt de gemoederen bezig. In zijn lezing, ‘The Fall of Rome: Media after Empire’ (download pdf) stelt Scott dat de […]

  6. Departing Press Council Chairman Tells it Like it Is – The Content Makers

    […] which is against any increased regulation – should prevail. This is part of the background to more recent stoushes between Scott and News […]

  7. Margaret Simons on the future of journalism at Brisbane Wordpool « Woolly Days

    […] then moved on to discuss ABC boss Mark Scott’s recent “end of empire” speech. She was cautious about whether this was a good or bad thing noting the Life of Brian skit about […]

  8. Is Rome burning? Murdoch picks a fight with the ABC « Woolly Days

    […] ability to provide content on the Internet, says Murdoch. Last week, ABC boss Mark Scott took up the cudgels and compared the empire of The Sun King to the Fall of Rome. The times they are a-changin’ in […]

  9. Ideas of journalism: Facing an uncertain media future - Dave Herrera (.org)

    […] Mark Scott, “The Fall of Rome: Media After Empire,” available (with additional commentary) as a PDF from […]

  10. News Limited Returns Fire – and Their Secret Plans. – The Content Makers

    […] week I described ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s landmark speech as a pre-emptive strike against those who would wish us to pay for viewing news and other content. […]

  11. Fox Force Five » Blog Archive » Twitter in the news, and the Media140 event in Sydney

    […] of following up both stories for Crikey and on her blog . (She also covered ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s recent AN Smith Lecture at the University of […]

  12. Tweetlinks, 10-14-09 [A Blog Around The Clock] « Technology Blogs

    […] Fall of Rome (PDF) “The habit of command is hard to break.” and The Fall of Rome: ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s Lecture […]

  13. Durutticolumn

    Margaret I think you need to take a cold shower On the ABC this morning describing Scott as a Media thinker Gimme a break. I worked with the guy for years he never had an idea on his own but now he is distilling the thoughts most of us have had for many years about the media. When we put it to him eight years ago that we needed to talk about internet and print integration 24 / hour news rooms and let’s try a few ideas he couldn’t see the point. All he did at Fairfax was help Fred screw the journalists and exit people from the building. He had no clue and sought no answers except job cuts as the circulation plunged under his leadership. In the end he just shrugged his shoulders and said it was a world wide phenomenon which was enough to get him a bonus. He left Fairfax demonstrating that he had had no ideas about how to tackle the new environment. The bloke who put up a paper entitled Imagine Fairfax without the classifieds was shown the door.
    Eric Beecher’s piece on his address to the boardroom shows nothing changed. Now Scott is the new messiah on media please. The flaw in his argument sticks out like you know whats. He has access to taxpayers funds of course he doesn’t have to worry about charging for content or firewalls.
    I think Murdoch is wrong on firewalls but don’t present Scott to us as some sort of genius. Even Fred Hilmer could run a media company on this sort of business model.
    What he gave us last night was a distillation of a lot of other people’s ideas.

  14. fredn

    The best bit is the speech, thanks for the link. He writes well, it was an entertaining read from start to finish, how can a reporter improve on that.

    This in my view is the problem, if interested people want access to the source material.

    Useful media is sorting out the noise, pointing to the source. Paying for opinion pieces, why would you do that? You get a much more diverse range of views reading the Huffington post comment section , a publication Scott mentioned towards the end of his speech because it has many editors and few reporters.

  15. AN Smith Lecture – Mr Mark Scott, Managing Director, ABC « Visible Procrastinations

    […] Unleashed] [4] ABC boss takes swipe at ‘emperor’ Murdoch (2009-Oct-15) [ABC News] [5] The Fall of Rome: ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s Lecture (2009-Oct-14) [Crikey] Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Cyber bullying special – […]

  16. Oh dear oh dear. News Limited slow and wrong. – The Content Makers

    […] Er, that’s  not quite what he said. See my reports and the copy of the speech here. […]

  17. Tweets that mention The Fall of Rome: ABC Managing Director Mark Scott’s Lecture – The Content Makers --

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Darcy Moore, amy denmeade and marcusod, marcusod. marcusod said: Good take on Scott speech @margaretsimons: central message is abt shift in power relationships from owners to audiences […]

  18. Media empires, the fall of Rome and the digital sublime « Ethical Martini

    […] For another interesting take on Scott’s speech I highly recommend Margaret Simons’ blog The Contentmakers. […]

  19. Martin Hirst

    Margaret, I haven’t read the whole speech yet, just about to before going to bed, it’s two hours later in Auckland.
    I just skimmed down a few pars and I love the Auden poem, but I can’t help but think that the lament that the media empires don’t get it and are somehow behind the game is last year’s news.
    If you look at the World Media Summit a couple of days ago in Beijing, Murdoch and the others who were there; the CEOs of Turner/Time Warner, AP and Reuters (for example), they are starting to find a path through the problems of paywalls and copyright.

    I think it’s a mistake to think that they will readily, or easily concede power to the audience, not matter what their rhetoric. They simply cannot afford to do it.
    Anyway, I’ll read the rest of the speech and perhaps reconsider.

    We can pick up this conversation at Media140 in Sydney, I look forward to it.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details