men's health

Apr 7, 2010

What do Australians really think about violence towards women? A new survey

A national survey of community attitudes around violence towards women was launched this morning in Melbourne. Among its many findings are that in 2009, one in 20 people believe women w

Melissa Sweet — Health journalist and <a href=Croakey co-ordinator" class="author__portrait">

Melissa Sweet

Health journalist and Croakey co-ordinator

A national survey of community attitudes around violence towards women was launched this morning in Melbourne. Among its many findings are that in 2009, one in 20 people believe women who are raped “ask for it”.

This is quite a change from 1995, when one in seven people held this view.

The survey, involving about 13,000 people, was funded by the Federal Government, and led by VicHealth, with the Social Research Centre and the Australian Institute of Criminology as research partners.

The piece below is based on a speech at the launch by Todd Harper, CEO of VicHealth and White Ribbon Ambassador. He writes that it’s time for men to challenge violence against women:

“Why should men get involved in what many have called a “women’s issue?”

It’s simple; domestic abuse and sexual assault against women are community issues impacting our wives and partners, mothers, daughters, friends – everyone.

One in three women over their life times will be physically assaulted. One in five will be sexually assaulted. The cost of domestic violence to the Australian economy was $13.6 billion in 2009.

The statistics are simply devastating, and demonstrate the very real need for changes in behaviour among Australians. We also have to change those aspects of our environments that tolerate an approach to women that promotes inequity, indifference or profound disrespect.

Understanding these community attitudes can help us learn from and understand what people think about violence against women, so that we are better placed to know how to prevent it.

Changing Cultures Changing Attitudes A National Survey on Community Attitudes To Violence against Women 2009 was launched in Melbourne today by the Hon Tanya Plibersek, MP, Federal Minister for the Status of Women. (It can be downloaded here)

The research, undertaken by VicHealth in conjunction with the Social Research Centre and the Australian Institute of Criminology, builds on a 1995 survey and establishes a benchmark against which changes in attitudes can be more closely monitored over time.

The National Survey involved approximately 13,000 men and women from across Australia. It included Indigenous Australians, people from culturally diverse communities and a sample of sixteen and seventeen year old respondents.

We know from the results that Australians are gradually changing their attitudes. Most believe that violence against women should not be a private affair, to be swept under the carpet and managed in the confines of the home.

The majority (98%) of people now recognise that domestic violence is a crime.

93% of people agree that forced sex in an intimate relationship is a crime.

Less than one in twenty believe that women who are raped ask for it, compared to one in seven people surveyed back in 1995.

So that’s the good news.

The downside is this.

Half of those surveyed believe that most women could leave violent relationships if they really wanted to, with eight out of ten finding it hard to understand why women stay in violent relationships.

13% of people still agree that women ‘often say no when they mean yes’ and roughly one in six (16%) agree that a woman ‘is partly responsible if she is raped when drunk or drug-affected.

Confusion still reigns over what constitutes sexual and domestic violence, if and when it can be excused, and who is most likely to be a victim of it.

Much of this rests with men and young people.

Based on the survey’s findings, men and boys are more likely than women and girls to hold attitudes that support violence.

They are less likely to believe that ‘controlling a partner by denying them money’ is a form of domestic violence.

They are also less likely to agree that ‘controlling the social life of a partner by preventing them from seeing friends or family’ is domestic violence.

The findings from this survey confirm the need for national leadership in coordinating a national violence against women prevention agenda.

The Federal Government has already announced an initial investment of $41 million in primary prevention activities including education strategies to change attitudes that condone and support violence against women.

A national plan to reduce violence against women is due to be finalised this year.

Last year, in Victoria, Premier Brumby released A Right To Respect – which provides us with our own State Plan for getting busy on prevention action.

I have no doubt that this kind of action by Governments is not only a good thing, but is in fact essential.

But the findings also confirm why men should step into what is seen as a ‘women’s issue’.

As a man, I know that not all men are violent.  But many of us have observed incidents that degrade or disrespect women.  We all need to speak up when this occurs, and to speak up against violence against women if we are to create an Australia where equal and respectful relationships between men and women are valued.

We can all play a role each day in communicating to other men, about our beliefs and values in relation to the women around us.

Very few men can put their ‘hand on heart’ and say they’ve never stood silent, perhaps even laughed awkwardly at jokes or comments made at women’s expense, or had a male friend make disparaging remarks or treated their partner in a way that made you feel uncomfortable.

The fact is that these moments, strung together, form part of the culture we are trying to change.

The good news is that change is indeed possible.

But it will take real action, from all of us – as well as governments – to re-set social norms and to change our cultural environments in ways that start to turn prevalence rates around.

We know that much of this depends on generational change, that will depend on programs and initiatives that can help to build our individual and collective skills in understanding how to develop, build and maintain relationships based on equality and mutual respect.

We need to work with those that can make this change in the places we occupy each day – in our workplaces, local government areas, schools, relationships, and in our homes.

I urge Australians, particularly men to read Changing Cultures Changing Attitudes, and to talk about the issues raised in the report with your sons, grandsons, nephews, fathers and footy mates.

Because it is only by understanding how we think and act, that we can truly begin to change our behaviour.

For the sake of the women in our lives.”


Leave a comment

14 thoughts on “What do Australians really think about violence towards women? A new survey

  1. International Women’s Day – some things to celebrate but more work to do

    […] concern that the level of domestic violence against women remains stubbornly high. As noted in a Crikey article in 2010: “It’s simple; domestic abuse and sexual assault against women are community issues […]

  2. The Pixel Project VAW e-News Digest: Edition Nine « The Pixel Project

    […] Australia: Survey on what Australians think about violence against women – 1 in 20 believe that wo…. […]

  3. Croakey

    David, here is Todd Harper’s response:

    The statistics came from the Australian Bureau of Statistics 2005 – Australian Bureau of Statistics (2005) Personal Safety Survey, ABS
    Cat. No. 4906.0, Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

    It is quoted in The National Plan to Reduce Violence against Women Immediate Government Actions, April 2009

  4. emmai

    yeah right !!!you said this:
    “They are less likely to believe that ‘controlling a partner by denying them money’ is a form of domestic violence.”

    I have a question:
    Are you more likely to believe that “controlling a partner by denying them sex” like so many women here do and use it as a weapon is a form of domestic violence!?

  5. Croakey

    David, the piece above quoting those figures was not written by Croakey but by VicHealth’s Todd Harper. I will ask him to respond to your query. Melissa

  6. Croakey

    In response to the previous query from “Most Peculiar Mama”, here is Todd Harper’s comment:

    “The full technical report (below) was released for White Ribbon day in late November last year.

    The final report (below), was published and formally launched to key stakeholders, (including education, sports, workplace, housing and police) this week.

    The importance of the publication and launch of the final report was to focus on what we need to do in response to the data in the technical report, (such as educating young men and boys and workplace education programs around the need for respectful relationships between men and women).

    Eliminating violence against women requires cultural change. Changing community attitudes is a critical part of the solution, and part of this rests in encouraging ongoing discussions in the community and media.”

  7. David Glenister

    Hi there Croakey. Can I ask where you got the stats of one in three women being physically assaulted and one in five women being sexually assaulted?

  8. Jenny Haines

    So it appears that the community education programs of the last 15 years have had some effect. Prevention programs do work. But of course we need more. One in 20 believing that women ask for rape is still far too many. At the treatment end, I was impressed by a TV program I saw recently where a psychologist was working with men in jail for rape and sexual crimes trying to change their attitudes to women. Tough work but someone has got to do it.

  9. sleepydumpling

    As a survivor of horrific domestic violence, thank you Mr Harper. Just… thank you.

  10. just

    Sticking my neck out here, but as a male that has been charged with DV 4 times I think I have some experience in the matter and issues.

    DV is not OK. Let me restate that, DV is not OK.

    But after spending $25K on defending myself, generally within a few months after I win a Child Support decision makes me wonder whether the DV statistics are severly skewed by cases such as mine. The lawyers and barristers I talk to through this process openly say that they dont feel they have ever seen a genuine DV case yet. By punishing me by winning Child Support decisions is actually an act of DV, but unfortunately the broader community does not really have an idea of what is going on. Those of BOTH genders that deserve protection are not receiving it, and those that dont seem to be getting screwed over by the great social experiment called DV laws.

    I noticed that the report highlights the amount of people who believe that false allegations of DV are the norm which is encouraging about creating true debate not skewed by those who make a living off painting males as the sole source of DV. Simply put we need a better system to protect and identify those people that are suffering DV without wasting resources on the false allegations.

  11. Croakey

    No I didn’t know this before you pointed it out. Thanks for the pointer. I will check with VicHealth to see what they say and report back….

  12. Most Peculiar Mama

    This survey was released MONTHS ago. Why is it news now?

    Tell me you knew this already?

  13. presactly

    Triple J’s Hack mentioned this survey today and the grab that stuck with me was:
    A similar diminishing of perpetrators’ responsibility for sexual violence was evident, in that substantial proportions agreed that:
    • rape occurs because of men ‘not being able to control their need for sex’ (34 percent in the general community).

    So not only do we as a community still need to counteract the ‘she asked for it’ school of ignorance, we also still need to get past the idea that sexual violence has anything to do with sex. It doesn’t. Rape and other assaults are to do with dominance and control, sex is the just the weapon used.

    I am heartened that more people in the community recognise these crimes as crimes, compared to the 1995 figures, but I definitely agree with the VicHealth CEO that blokes now need to get involved and call their mates out on off behaviour.

    Here’s hoping for improved attitudes AND outcomes in the years ahead.

  14. happyfemmo

    I completely agree. Men & women should be involved in that campaign against violence against women and children (& all people). Perhaps part of the journey towards reducing the incidence of domestic & family violence and sexual assault is to start acknowleding and celebrating caring characteristics in men, the same way these characteristics are celebrated in women.
    We also need to stop victim blaming & excusing the behaviour of the perpetrator of violence, whether they are male or female. (Both men & women excuse violent behaviour if the perpetrator had a violent upbringing). And need to look at our own behaviour and really go back to that old saying, that we should treat others how we wished to be treated.
    Committing violence against others is a choice & we can make the choice to be non-violent.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details