air safety

Dec 14, 2012

Qatar, United 787 incidents can hinder ETOPS approval

A newly delivered Qatar 787 Dreamliner is grounded at London Heathrow with an electrical fault said to be similar to the one that caused a United 787 to make a recent emergency landing

Ben Sandilands — Editor of Plane Talking

Ben Sandilands

Editor of Plane Talking

A newly delivered Qatar 787 Dreamliner is grounded at London Heathrow with an electrical fault said to be similar to the one that caused a United 787 to make a recent emergency landing in the US.

As reported in considerable detail by Bloomberg, the United incident occurred on 4 December and the Qatar incident on 9 December. Boeing is quoted as saying that it isn’t certain that it was an identical issue with a faulty generator.

Despite the rather sharp criticisms made by Qatar Airways CEO Akbar Al Baker in the report, such glitches are not unusual in the introduction of a new type of airliner into service, even one as late in terms of its development and certification as the ‘game changing plastic fantastic’ 787, a throw away line that Boeing marketing used in the middle of the last decade, and regretted at various times since then.

Of more concern to all, in Boeing and among its 787 customers, and in the FAA, will be the implications of electrical system unreliabilities or vulnerabilities to the ETOPS approvals for the type. All western twin-engined airliners are now delivered with ETOPS 180 capabilities, which if their national safety regulators agree, means that they can fly routes which are at no point more than 180 minutes away from a suitable airfield at single engine speed. Boeing has made a claimed capability of ETOPS 330 minutes in its 777s and 787s a selling point.

However ETOPS approvals are not permanent. They are subject to very strict operational reliability criteria being maintained, and engine or electrical failures for whatever reason  can cause the revocation of ETOPS approvals until it can be demonstrated to the satisfaction of air safety regulators that the necessary reliability is restored.

One of the reasons why ETOPS restrictions apply is that in the unlikely event of an engine failing during cruise, single engine flight will then occur at reduced altitude and significantly less efficient fuel consumption on the remaining engine because of increased aerodynamic drag.

Reliability is the fundamental basis for the massive shift to the use of twin engined designs in airline operations since the mid 80s. But it is a continuing requirement, under constant review, and the process of maintaining engines and critical systems to meet those requirements is meticulous and unforgiving.

Qatar Airways is expected to become the first airline to operate a 787 to Australia in commercial service from 1 February between Perth and Doha.  At this stage, China Southern is considered highly likely to follow shortly afterwards with flights between Sydney and Guangzhou, with Jetstar now expected to put its first Dreamliners into service on routes and times yet to be announced in mid-2013.

(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)


Leave a comment

One thought on “Qatar, United 787 incidents can hinder ETOPS approval

  1. David Klein

    Having been directly involved in ETOPS approval for the introduction of the Airbus A330-200 into Qantas I feel Jetstar are in for a rude shock if they think they will have 180 minutes of CASA ETOPS approval with their initial B787 Dreamliner operations. The stepped approach under FAA AC 120-42B will most likely be enforced by CASA, particularly with radical new engine types and the first aircraft in the fleet may well be limited to 60 or 90 minutes for a considerable proving period.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details