Facebook Google Menu Linkedin lock Pinterest Search Twitter

Advertisement

Federal Election 2013

Aug 11, 2013

Share

A dedicated thread for your blow-by-blow commentary of the leaders’ debate at the National Press Club as it unfolds.

Advertisement

Advertisement

We recommend

From around the web

Powered by Taboola

442 comments

442 thoughts on “Live debate thread

  1. gloryconsequence

    Guytaur – no one watches Ch 10

  2. mexicanbeemer

    Quite bland debate.

    Tone 5.5/10
    Kevin 5/10

    Wont change too many votes.

  3. lefty e

    [Ch 9 had 100 “swingers” in the studio.]

    If this is true (and I dont know), then it went very well indeed for Rudd tonight.

    Ch7, OTOH, has a self-selecting app download sample of voters (ie clearly unreliable), and lets face it: they chose Kennett (with no balancing voice) as their Federal election commentator.

    Advantage Rudd. Onward!

  4. Diogenes

    I think Rudd won the debate but Abbott survived so he got a tactical win out of it.

  5. guytaur

    “@michaelebeid: Tues 8:30pm @insightSBS, @SenatorWong explains why Marriage Equality is important 4 a secular society like ours @AMEQUALITY @AlexGreenwich”

  6. Carey Moore

    Rudd’s biggest problems was his tendency to obfuscate and try to change the topic, even aggressively. That Sydney line was just stupid. Rudd needs Sydney votes to win, telling them “You’re not the only city, deal with it!” is not a good way to get them!

    Abbott came off as a tad awkward and cocky and his slogans did seem rehearsed. He also really struggled to put any meat in his pledges, relying on generic “make the economy stronger” non-pledges.

  7. poroti

    😆 😆 😆 Kroger on Sky boosting Kerosene Bishop as a tireless worker for aged care.

  8. feeney

    Unfortunately the worm doesn’t get a vote.

  9. Gaffhook

    Bugger, I have just wasted an hour of my life.

    Why was Kevin Rudd debating George Bush, i thought he was supposed to be debating Abbott.

  10. ruawake

    Everyone bar channel seven gives it to Rudd.

    But a bookie was taking bets on the debate, based on 7 results and the Liberal Party was tweeting its members to download the 7 App.

    Disgraceful.

  11. Rosemour or Less

    thanks pith..but it doesn’t work for me anymore….my heart on my sleeve …pulsing, bleeding everywhere…..I’m pathetic

  12. Mr Squiggle

    I think Rudd won with the viewers…

    …and…

    Tony won with the press gallery.

    This is going to be interesting

  13. silmaj

    The debate was pathetic. No more to be said

  14. Mod Lib

    $5.50 now!

    Some big bets must be happening!!!!!

  15. Marrickville Mauler

    Miranda # 250: Quite right! Aer not the workhouses in operation?

    Happy Christmas to you too… NOT

  16. outside left

    What was with Rasputins eyelids? Makeup gone wrong?

  17. davidwh

    SportsBet has been sitting on $4.80 all day and hasn’t moved following the debate.

    I thought the debate was pretty dull with neither of the participants prepared to really confront the other for fear of upsetting the worm. Hardly good for open democratic debate.

  18. Carey Moore

    The only way that this debate was going to make a big difference was if one of them made a huge blunder that could lead the headlines tomorrow. In a sterile format like that of the debate, it never was going to happen.

  19. guytaur

    “@rauribarker: KRudd, You just got my vote with that statement.
    #leadersdebate #marriageequality”

  20. confessions

    I wonder how poroti is going….

  21. Lady Miranda Ann Caulfeild Ackermann-Boltt

    Who actually won the debate today seems a matter for debate, but one thing seems clear. There will be no more debates, unless Krudd agrees to the town hall forums suggested by Mr Abbott. It seems all so appropriate that Mr Abbott is able to set the terms of the debates (or lack thereof). In either case I’m enjoying watching Krudd’s final struggles as he slowly sinks into peat bogs of politics.

  22. the spectator

    the most important thing about tonights debate was seeing the clear comparison between Abbott and Rudd and Abbott came across wooden, boring and totally uninspiring. that is the critical outcome the comparison of the two leaders on offer.

  23. Mick77

    The worm outcomes and the conclusions on who won would have been exactly the same if they’d inadvertently blanked out the channels for an hour. Debates don’t alter people’s minds but they reinforce what people already believe and people look for the one line that confirms their perceptions .. there, he said that, you see etc. Waste of time and AEC should just declare election for Libs now and save a lot of time and money – 90 seats to 60 roughly.

  24. mexicanbeemer

    The SSM issue may become a sleeper issue during the campaign.

  25. zoidlord

    @Mick77/427

    lol. AEC to declare already?

  26. BH

    Lefty e Can you explain re Moreton view please

  27. lefty e

    If I TRY VERY HARD to be objective, Id say the following:

    I though Abbott was doing better than Rudd in the first quarter, but then Rudd relaxed and was more fluent and engaging.

    Yes, I dont think Rudd handled the Sydney Airport all that well. But he did well on NBN, productivity and marriage equality.

    Abbott looked shifty on costings – its just not a good look at all. A lot of punters will recall it was Costello who set up these tests of an oposition. Some of his stuff on the CO2 tax seems stale now: he’s debating someone who is no longer there.

    Rudd will have done better tonight with undecideds, but Abbott didnt screw the pooch either – in general I dont think this format is likel to engage punters as much as it does us.

  28. ShowsOn

    I think Abbott will refuse further debates as they are too big a risk for him.

  29. Lady Miranda Ann Caulfeild Ackermann-Boltt

    Admittedly, Mitt Romney did get a very big bounce out of winning the first debate against Obama. Had Rudd tanked in the debate it would have been all over red rover (it probably already is).

  30. guytaur

    “@TwitterAU: Peak moment of the #LeadersDebate was 1,952 Tweets per minute at 7:25pm AEST, during #samesex marriage discussion.”

  31. Mick77

    ML
    Which bookie are you watching? sportingbet moved to 5.25 before the debate began and hasn’t moved. Do you have a link for what you’re perving at? (We know that sprocket’s a fraud on betting reports like on most things.)

  32. ShowsOn

    [ there, he said that, you see etc. Waste of time and AEC should just declare election for Libs now and save a lot of time and money – 90 seats to 60 roughly.]
    WTF? You undemocratic fool

  33. poroti

    confessions

    First tummy gurgles have hit. Reckon I got ten minutes left. Still got another liter of the ambrosia to drink.
    Uh oh. Make that about 2 minutes left. Byeeeeeeeee.

  34. guytaur

    @hughriminton: Thanks to the 8000+ tweeps who voted in our #Debate twitterpoll tonight – calling it for @KRuddMP on “believability” @channeltennews

  35. lefty e

    BH – ABC24 went to four undecided voters in moreton for a qualitative feedback session.

    All 4 were quite articulate, and the general vibe was unimpressed with format, contemporary politics in general – wanting deeper explanations of policy and fewer cheap slogans.

  36. pithicus

    Rosemour
    you might get a pleasant surprise come sep 7.
    If the polls are awful 1 week out then it’s time to really worry.

  37. Laocoon

    liyana @ 348
    [Menzies!!! Did he say Menzies!!! ROFL- how ridiculous!]
    Got me thinking.

    Menzies won his last election in 1963.

    To be of voting age then, one had to be born by 1942.

    That is to say, for the 2013 election, one needs to be 71 years of age or more, to have been eligible to vote in an election with Menzies as PM.

    Looking at last year’s demographic stats, that would be at maximum, 12.3% of the voting age bloc. And a reasonable proportion of them surely would be immigrants from after 1963, who would not have ever experienced a Menzies election.

  38. William Bowe

    Wrapping it up here now, so it’s back to the earlier thread.

Advertisement

Telling you what the others don't. FREE for 21 days.