Miranda Devine

Apr 15, 2011

I watched a revolting show that was less offensive than The Australian’s beatup

Let's be rational about this. The hyperbole in

Let’s be rational about this.

The hyperbole in Larissa Behrendt’s tweet about Bess Price, who at the time was on Q&A on ABC defending John Howard’s “intervention” in the Northern Territory, refers to a disturbing image – apparently courtesy of ABC-TV’s notoriously offensive Wild West show Deadwood – but there was no defamatory link drawn between that activity and Ms Price. The tweet simply rated the two on a scale of “offensiveness” to Ms Behrendt:

That might have been a slightly exaggerated contrast to draw (as is the whole point of hyperbole), but it’s not “obscene vilification”. It’s not an attempt to “control” or “silence” a different view. It’s not “outrageous” or “marginalising” anyone. It’s a tweet expressing Ms Behrendt’s view that what Ms Price was saying was extremely offensive to her. Ms Price’s apparent determination to seek legal recourse for someone finding her “offensive” is laughable.

Obviously The Australian, and the Liberal Party, and Ms Price, and a number of other far-right commentators, think they can ride the shock from the revolting Deadwood image all the way past the fact that it wasn’t actually applied to Ms Price other than by way of contrast, and use it to damn an opponent, an Aboriginal woman, who has dared to take on Andrew Bolt in the courtroom. They can raise the profile of another Aboriginal woman who is in favour of their “intervention” at the cost of a critic of it.

It’s pretty shameless stuff, but they’re not finished with it yet.

PS Behrendt has sent Ms Price an apology, but Ms Price apparently won’t accept it until it’s in public – you know, more in public than being quoted in full in The Australian. How about giving it in the same forum as the original – a tweet? That should be more than sufficient.

UPDATE: Via Tanja in the comments the twitter conversation surrounding the tweet. If anyone had any doubt that
(a) Bahrendt was referring to what Price was saying on Q&A; and
(b) the “show” mentioned was the episode of Deadwood that was currently airing on ABC – well, that should clear it up.

Taking tweets out of context is fundamentally misleading, because the 140 character limit means that most tweets assume that the reader is aware of to what they’re replying. So, obviously, the tweet does not mean the same thing to its original audience as when it is displayed without context.

Do I really need to start randomly picking 140 character strings from News Ltd articles to demonstrate why taking them out of context is not a fair reflection of their authors ‘meaning?

UPDATE #2: Miranda “rogering gerbils” Devine pulls out every far-right cliche she can think of:

We should be grateful for the tweet because it gave us a rare undisguised insight into the depraved and rancid core of the reflexively leftist, inner-urban, ivory-tower thinking

DING! DING! DING! If she’d managed to pop in “elites”, she’d surely have won herself a prize.

(Visited 48 times, 1 visits today)


60 thoughts on “I watched a revolting show that was less offensive than The Australian’s beatup

  1. Murdoch Deleted Tweet Treat | Pure Poison

    […] Rupert deleted the tweet. Surely that’s the end of the matter and it would be irresponsible to publish someone’s tweet after they’ve deleted […]

  2. And Miranda’s unhinging gets sillier | Pure Poison

    […] for the reference to Deveny and Behrendt’s old tweets: Excuse me for being still a bit self absorbed after the week I’ve had, but had I […]

  3. Elsewhere – S-x with a horse: getting done over by The Australian | Pure Poison

    […] Brull via The Drum. (Our coverage of the Larissa Behrendt beatup here.) Comments (0) | […]

  4. Yeah, Janet, really serious. (Or: Why are they still going on about this?) | Pure Poison

    […] Australian’s Ms Albrechtsen still hasn’t gotten over Larissa Behrendt: It’s a serious debate about free […]

  5. Looking after their own. | Pure Poison

    […] just not fair, Miranda ‘Rogering Gerbils‘ Devine had only last week told us how Larissa Behrendt’s twitter stream had exposed, a rare insight into the core of the leftist, ivory-tower thinking that pervades every level of […]

  6. confessions

    The OO is still going on about this. They’ve had various opinion pieces all week, and today an editorial about aboriginal disadvantage, but somehow weaving in Berehendt’s tweet.

    The qanda program was 2 weeks ago.

  7. Twitter and News | Pure Poison

    […] Recent targets have included Catherine “hope Bindi Irwin gets laid” Deveny, Miranda “rogering gerbils” Devine, and Larissa “show where guy had sex with a horse less offensive than Bess Price” Behrendt. […]

  8. zoot

    Possibly a bit off topic, but has Mr Bolt offered any public support for Ms Behrendt’s right to freedom of speech?

  9. quantize

    ‘I’ll also reflect on my taxes paying for your ABC smearing my side of politics.’

    Oh stop whining, pull yer head out yer ass…you have political blinkers of the worst kind on if you think Labor has been getting a great run on the ABC

  10. Jeremy Sear

    Everybody back on topic. I’ve snipped Bellewhatsit’s continuing off-topic after I warned him/her. There’s an open thread for random rants.

    This post is about the Australian’s attempt to foment a war between indigenous supporters of the intervention and opponents of the intervention, with a bit of a personal revenge because Behrendt dared to sue one of their columnists.

Share this article with a friend

Just fill out the fields below and we'll send your friend a link to this article along with a message from you.

Your details

Your friend's details